Court to Decide Whether Prosecution in Dekraai Case Misused Jailhouse Informants

Dekraai's attorney argues an informant was housed near Dekraai in a way to make it appear it was a coincidence and got the defendant to talk about the killings. The hearing starts Tuesday.

Scott Evans Dekraai. Patch file photo.
Scott Evans Dekraai. Patch file photo.

An Orange County Superior Court judge is set to begin hearing evidence Tuesday on allegations that Orange County sheriff's officials and prosecutors broke the law in using jailhouse informants in the case against the man accused of the worst mass killing in Orange County history.

Attorneys for Scott Evans Dekraai, who is charged with killing eight people in the Salon Meritage in Seal Beach, are trying to persuade Orange County Superior Court Judge Thomas Goethals to remove the death penalty as an option for prosecutors against Dekraai.

They also want the Orange County District Attorney's Office removed from the case in favor of the Attorney General's Office, which is opposed to the move.

Assistant Public Defender Scott Sanders, who wrote a 500-plus page motion alleging government misconduct in the handling of jailhouse snitches tasked with gathering evidence for prosecutors, is expected to begin the evidentiary hearing Tuesday with testimony from longtime informant Fernando Perez.

Sanders argues that Perez was housed near Dekraai in a way to make it appear it was a coincidence and got the defendant to talk about the killings.

Other more explosive allegations include prosecutors not file a case against one suspect in a gang homicide to hide alleged misconduct.

Sanders, who also represents Daniel Patrick Wozniak, another defendant facing the death penalty for a dismemberment murder, has made similar allegations in that case and is seeking to have the ultimate punishment removed as an option in that case as well.

Sanders' motion also alleges misconduct in multiple cases involving state and federal crackdowns on Mexican Mafia-led violence in Orange County jails dubbed Operation Black Flag and Operation Smokin' Aces. Goethals on Friday removed the lead state prosecutor on those cases, Erik Petersen, from one of those cases for failing to hand over possible exculpatory evidence to defense attorneys in a jail-beating case.

In a rare move, the judge found that Petersen made a so-called Brady violation, named after a landmark case where the U.S. Supreme Court held that a defendant is entitled to get any and all evidence that may prove innocence.

Assistant District Attorney Dan Wagner, who is prosecuting Dekraai, has earlier said Sanders' motion was "filled with untruths."

Wagner and Petersen are expected to be called to testify in the hearing, which could take place at various times over the next couple of weeks.

--City News Service

Jeffrey Hathcock March 18, 2014 at 12:37 PM
Regarding the Scott Dekraii murder case, I fail to see where the testimony of a jail house informant should have any bearing on the death penalty; especially, when you consider the fact that Dekraii admitted to the killings, he had a motive, he had the murder weapon when caught and everyone on the planet knows he's guilty. And, this judge, Goethals seems to be a weak-kneed liberal twit who appears to be succumbing to the desires of Dekraii's defense team and will most-likely takwe the death penalty off the table. In which case, we, the public will have to support this monster Dekraii for the rest of his miserable life. Think about this: What's more inhumane? Slaughtering 8 innocent people, mostly women who were at the beauty shop, God bless them, or executing this scum bag who murdered them; ending their lives and forever ruining the lives of their families and friends? I find it inconceivable that the same bleeding-hearts who so vociferously are against the death penalty have no qualms about aborting babies. It's time we took back our judicial system from these idiots and see that justice is served; albeit by injection, gas, firing squad or hanging. And, if anyone has any qualms about taking these monsters out, just step aside and I'll gladly oblige! Jeff Hathcock


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »